Historian Carl Berger offered a dramatic new understanding of Canada’s past

Sometimes a nation’s story gets shaken in such a way as to make its teeth rattle. University of Toronto historian Carl Clinton Berger did just that in 1970. He turned the study of Canada’s past topsy-turvy with his book The Sense of Power: Studies in the Ideas of Canadian Imperialism, 1867-1914. His book, as ordinary Canadians and academics came to see, was not really about Canadians’ attachment to imperialism. It was a masterful introduction to Canadian intellectual history, to the history of ideas and how they develop, spread and transform across time.

Photograph illustrating Historian Carl Berger offered a dramatic new understanding of Canada’s past

The Argument Carl Berger Made About Canada’s Past

The book brought Prof. Berger to the finding that what he was really looking at was not an English-Canadian notion of imperialism but an English-Canadian notion of nationalism. And as historians Douglas Owram and Gerald Friesen wrote in the introduction to Thinkers and Dreamers, their 2011 collection of essays honouring Prof. Berger’s work, The Sense of Power had a huge impact on how Canadian history was thought about, put into words and taught.

The principles of intellectual history, Prof. Berger declared, did not exist in a vacuum; they needed to be understood within the context of their specific political, social, cultural and material environments. And as he laid bare these layers of intellectual history, Prof. Berger revealed that what he was looking at was not really imperialist thought with a maple sugar coating – it was Canadian nationalism. For a neighbouring discussion, see Opinion: Nigeria’s 2027 Elections and the Leadership Question.

His approach combined a narrative presentation of history – stories about what people said and thought about their country – with the body of literature dealing with technical historical matters, including techniques, theories and principles of historical research as well as the critical examination of material from primary and secondary sources subject to scholarly criteria.

The dust jacket of Prof. Berger’s book showed a two-cent Canadian stamp from Christmas 1898, bearing a map of the globe with countries belonging to the then-British Empire coloured red. A big, red blob of Canada was shown at the map’s centre, with the inference that Canada would be a dominant partner in a reorganized British Empire. But really, what the story of the stamp reveals was Prof. Berger’s argument that allusions to imperialism were a form of Canadian nationalism taking place in the country’s intellectual discourse between the seminal dates of Confederation in 1867 and the outbreak of the First World War in 1914.

Why His Work Still Shapes the Conversation

Prof. Owram and Prof. Friesen wrote in their introduction to Thinkers and Dreamers that whereas earlier work on political history in Canada was primarily limited to depictions of the ideas of politicians, the opinions of journalists and sometimes references to historiography, Prof. Berger probed the thinking and utterances of a much broader swath of Canadians. He examined and recorded myths and legends that Canadians had about their country and looked into their origins. He used textual analysis and archival research to figure out what past writers and speakers actually meant to do with their words rather than judging them in the context of modern settings.

In his revisionist interpretation of what was largely considered to be a Canada glued to imperialist thinking, he assembled his findings into what Prof. Owram and Prof. Friesen wrote of as a lucidly constructed, carefully documented and stylishly written argument to the contrary.

Comments

No approved comments yet.

Comments are reviewed by an administrator before they appear.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *